So. If you just happened to have a hankering to replace your old and battered Fiat Cinquecento, and you didn't actually drive very many miles, but wanted a new-ish car which was at least some fun at the same time as being practical, would you buy...
Toyota Aygo (Or the Citroen C1, or that other one which is basically an Aygo...)
Other, specified below. But note that Fiats aren't allowed, because while I like the cars, the local main dealers are a bunch of complete fsckwits and I'm never going to deal with them again.